Fit As A Physio | Mosman
  • Home
  • COVID-19
  • Book Online
  • Reviews
  • FAQS
  • Fees
  • Contact
  • SHOP

Blog

Are You Out Of Alignment?

20/11/2020

1 Comment

 
Picture
​I treat a lot of people that have:
  • back pain,
  • neck pain,
  • pelvis pain,
  • hip pain.


​Very commonly they’ll tell me something is “out of alignment”. Either that’s what it feels like, or they’ve had treatment from a therapist that has told them that, or they’ve talked to a friend who has said “maybe your ‘X’ is out?” and that makes perfect sense to them.

The concept of something being “out of alignment” is not a paradigm I’ve ever been taught or taught to patients. My understanding of it as an idea is that it comes from an osteopathic and chiropractic model where pain and illness are meant to originate from vertebral “subluxations”. A vertebra is “out of place”. The subluxation model is now being discouraged by chiropractic associations worldwide as not being valid, but it has definitely seeped into public consciousness. A lot of people when they have back pain will try and describe how it feels and come up with the explanation that they’ve “put their back out”. Patients grab hold of a simple idea that seems to makes sense.

When a patient uses this sort of terminology I used to play along with it because I understood what they were saying and I found I upset a lot of patients if I tried to correct them. They had paid good money to see a chiropractor who’s told them their pelvis was out of alignment, they’ve agreed that’s what it felt like so they’ve bought into the idea. When I question the concept directly it can be upsetting. If someone to whom you’ve paid money tells you something, and they’re a nice enough person, and they seem like they care about you and know what they’re talking about, you believe them. To then be the second therapist offering an opinion and say something different can be tricky and I usually word it incorrectly and put the patient right off side.
Picture
Anyway, I used to let it slide because it’s easier for everyone, I can get on with treatment using my own paradigm, and I didn’t think any harm was done.

But I’ve now changed my mind on staying quiet. 

I saw a lady today who’s been seeing an osteopath twice a week for a year - thousands of dollars - for a radiculopathy from her lumbar spine which has now progressed to a foot drop. Every session her “pelvis was out”. She doesn’t know how it keeps happening. Her only solution was to pay this “expert” for a “re-alignment”. It’s a very common story. I got so upset today. This lady was in tears - she felt so helpless.

I think this sort of treatment is criminal. It makes someone a helpless victim by diagnosing them with something that they have absolutely no control of themselves - the pelvis just keeps going out mysteriously. And sell a solution: “I can put it back for you. Come in twice a week”. Nothing you can do to help yourself. 

The language is dangerous and damaging and takes advantage of a patient that trusts you are a professional providing an honest service.

When a therapist talks about something being out of alignment I hope they are using the terminology as a euphemism rather than believing something is actually out of place. Because we know it’s not. 

So the therapist is either:
  • unknowingly perpetuating an idea that is harmful because they are ignorant,
  • or deliberately deceiving patients for financial gain.

So I’m no longer tolerating the language of something being out of place or out of alignment.

​It’s not, and it’s harmful to talk like that.


​I used to think physios were better than that and the language of alignment was just for other professions. I used to be OK with it because it was Chiro’s and Osteo’s, not physios. But more often these days the language of something being “out” is creeping into physiotherapy. Muscle Energy Technique (MET) is a type of treatment physios are using to treat the hips, sacrum, pelvis, and back pain. “Rotations”, “counter-rotations”, “up-slips”, and “down-slips”. The way they teach it seems like they actually believe it’s a physical/mechanical movement rather than a conceptualised euphemistic explanation. I don’t think it’s a path the physio profession should go down. 

I understand how it happens. An “expert” is in town selling a course. You pay money for the course, you’ve bought the product and are invested in it working, you give it a go with patients and get good results. It’s the same cascade that makes the patient buy in.

Next minute it seems like everyone’s pelvis is twisted. It’s an epidemic.
Picture
How can different professions, and even two therapists in the one profession, come up with completely different explanations for what’s going on? I think that speaks to the size of the problem of back pain and there not being a single treatment option that helps everyone. (Well actually there is and that’s exercise - but it’s harder for people to make money from selling exercise.)

This is a bit of a rant and I’m almost nervous to write it down because there are some well respected therapists across a number of professions who are a lot smarter, have better jobs, and earn a lot more money than me, who speak about things being out of alignment.

Not me. Don’t worry. Your back is strong. Your back is stable. Your back is resilient. It’s sore now, but that is largely unrelated to structure and mechanics. There’s definitely nothing broken, out of place, or alignment.


1 Comment

Health News 27/9/18

27/9/2018

1 Comment

 
Picture
  • The osteoarthritis treatment 'fads' that don't work, GP guidelines
  • Scans, surgeries and opioids rarely the right answer for back pain
  • Who is our health regulator, AHPRA, and does it operate effectively?
  • Hate High-Intensity Exercise? Try It. You Might Like It.
  • Needless procedures: knee arthroscopy is one of the most common but least effective surgeries
  • Changing the playing field - the growing role of a Sports and Exercise Physiotherapist
  • Exercise-induced bronchoconstriction, or why I can't stop wheezing after a run
1 Comment

Health News

16/4/2018

0 Comments

 
Picture
  • Middle back pain: Causes and relief
  • How Exercise Can Keep Aging Muscles and Immune Systems ‘Young’
  • Patellar tendonitis (jumper's knee): Treatment and recovery
  • Get Up and Move. It May Make You Happier.
  • Work. Walk 5 Minutes. Work.
  • Micro concussions may alter football players' brains
  • Why Exercise Alone May Not Be the Key to Weight Loss
0 Comments

Health News

14/9/2017

1 Comment

 
Picture
  • Bring On the Exercise, Hold the Painkillers
  • To Prevent Back Pain, Orthotics Are Out, Exercise Is In
  • A new study suggests that getting up from your chair every half-hour or so could reduce the risk of an early death.
  • Asthma and ibuprofen: What are the effects?
  • Is running on a treadmill as good as running outside?
  • Patellofemoral syndrome: Symptoms, causes, and treatment
  • Trimalleolar fracture: Recovery, surgery, and outlook
  • Just 30 minutes of activity on 5 days could save lives
  • Just 1 hour of exercise per week could prevent depression
1 Comment

Health News

21/8/2017

0 Comments

 
Picture
  • Does platelet-rich plasma for the knee work?
  • Prolonged sitting and frailty a deadly combination
  • ​Lisfranc fracture: Causes, symptoms, and treatment
  • Study: Active parents have more active kids
  • Why Those Who Exercise Have a Good Head on Their Shoulders
  • Spondyloarthritis: Symptoms, treatments, and causes
  • What app is good for my back?
  • Age Like a Former Athlete
  • What is a bunion and do I need to get mine treated?
0 Comments

Health News 06/03/17

23/2/2017

0 Comments

 
Running
  • Health apps could be doing more harm than good, warn scientists
  • Running economy barefoot, in minimalist shoes and traditional running shoes
  • Exercise and pain: Discomfort, 'good pain' and knowing when to stop
  • Is this back pain killing me?
  • Physical activity behavior predicts endogenous pain modulation in older adults
  • Fitbit’s decline is a reflection of the end of the over-hyped promise of wearables
  • EXERCISE CAN HELP PROTECT CHILDREN FROM DEPRESSION
  • Frequent, Brisk Walks May Aid Those With Early Alzheimer’s
  • Is changing footstrike pattern beneficial to runners?
  • Kick-arse conversation on body image for International Women’s Day
0 Comments

Health News 21/02/17

15/2/2017

0 Comments

 
Sugar Tax
  • Why the government should tax unhealthy foods
  • Why sitting is not the ‘new smoking’
  • Lower back ache? Be active and wait it out, new guidelines say​
  • New study shows more time walking means less time in hospital
  • New study reveals how high-mileage running makes muscles and tendons more efficient
  • Which supplements work?
  • Four things Australia could do to tackle the obesity crisis
  • Increasing daily step count reduces days in hospital, study shows
0 Comments

Health News 14/02/17

7/2/2017

2 Comments

 
Physio Mosman
  • Fibromyalgia Flares: Warning Signs and Treatments
  • What is a balanced diet anyway?
  • Ouch! The drugs don’t work for back pain, but here’s what does
  • Five Important Facts About Multiple Sclerosis
  • Doctors can be helped to prescribe other options
  • Is Fibromyalgia Real?
  • Thigh muscle specific strength and the risk of incident knee osteoarthritis
  • Do cold showers cool you down?
2 Comments

Health News 2/2/17

31/1/2017

0 Comments

 
Physio Mosman
  • Fitter Seniors May Have Healthier Brains
  • Lack of Exercise Might Invite Dementia
  • Natural Remedies for Rheumatoid Arthritis
  • Anti-inflammatory diet reduces bone loss, hip fracture risk in women
  • Could physical activity protect children from depression?
  • Why it’s time we paid employees to exercise at work
  • How your sleep patterns could be contributing to your back pain
  • Spectacularly unreliable MRI “results”
0 Comments

Health News 16/01/17

9/1/2017

0 Comments

 
Physio Mosman
  • The lure of cycling
  • Is weekend exercise just as good as being active every day?
  • Physical Activity Reduces Total and Cardiovascular Mortality and Cardiovascular Disease Incidence in Older Adults
  • Acute Low Back Pain? Do Not Blame the Weather
  • Just 45 minutes of exercise a week can benefit older adults with arthritis
  • Sedentary behavior raises dementia risk as much as genetic factors​
0 Comments

Health News 21/12/16

13/12/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
  • Running actually lowers inflammation in knee joints
  • Effectiveness of foot orthoses and shock-absorbing insoles for the prevention of injury
  • Pokémon Go boosts exercise levels – but only for a short period
  • Your left hand knows what your right hand is doing
  • ACTIVE TRANSPORTATION IS THE KEY TO HEALTHIER CITIES
  • Vitamin C and Back Pain
0 Comments

Health News 06/12/16

2/12/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
  • Got high cholesterol? Here are five foods to eat and avoid
  • Should a Simple Fitness Check Be Part of Your Checkup?
  • Bone Bruise: Symptoms, Treatment, and Outlook
  • Childhood Obesity Causes & Consequences
  • Complex regional pain syndrome
  • Running sounds contain clues for injury prevention
  • Back pain may raise risk of mental health problems
0 Comments

Back Pain Management Plan

8/11/2015

11 Comments

 
Back Pain Management Plan

​Back pain is a big problem.  Everyone gets it.  It's the most common thing I treat.  About a quarter of the patients I see have back pain.  There's a massive disease burden.  It's expensive.

And it can seem complicated.  Everyone's got different advice about what to do.  There's not one thing that fixes it.  It can seem a bit out of control.  And that can make it worse again.  Stupid little things aggravate it.  It doesn't seem fair.  Stress.  Anxiety.

Usually there's not anything magical I can do to give you immediate relief.  We work on little gains that you can achieve regularly by yourself throughout the day and it gradually improves.  It takes a bit of work.

My main goal when you come in for treatment is to give you control.  Once you have a sense of control it doesn't hurt as much.  I frame this as a "BACK PAIN MANAGEMENT PLAN"...

- KNOW WHAT AGGRAVATES IT -

For example, this could be:
  • Sitting
  • Driving
  • Bending
  • Lifting
  • Twisting
  • Running 
  • Standing

- KNOW WHAT RELIEVES IT -

This could be:
  • Tablets
  • Heat
  • Massage
  • Stretches
  • General exercise
  • Avoiding prolonged sitting

- KNOW HOW TO PREVENT THE NEXT EPISODE -

This could be:
  • Strengthening exercises
  • Stretching
  • General exercise
  • Avoiding prolonged sitting

We need to pick the one or two most important things from each of these lists
​

11 Comments

Sitting Is The New Smoking

26/5/2015

19 Comments

 
I quite enjoy the concept of Micromorts & Microlives.  Our average life expectancy can be divided into one-million, half-hour units.  I enjoy the maths of risk.  The things that add or subtract units of our lives.  

For example:
  • 2 cigarettes shortens your life by 30 minutes
  • 1 standard drink adds 30 minutes (the 2nd drink takes it away again)
  • 20 minutes of moderate exercise adds an hour to life expectancy
  • 2 hours sitting shortens your life by 30 minutes

Sitting Is Dangerous

Sitting is the new smoking
There’s been some media over the last couple of years suggesting that “sitting is the new smoking”.

Research now tells us that the number of hours we sit each day is an independent predictor of our health, similar to other factors like age, smoking status, obesity, & exercise.  It turns out that sitting for 10 hours a day is harmful for your health whether or not you exercise, how old you are, whether or not you smoke, & whether or not you’re fat or thin.  Sitting is bad for you.

The longer we sit, the less healthy we are.  There are a couple of reasons…  

1) Back Pain

Sitting is the primary cause of low back pain, which is a leading cause of disability in the general population (second only to depression), with nearly four million Australians suffering at any one time. Total treatment costs in Australia exceed $4 billion a year.  Back pain is the most common musculoskeletal problem, accounting for one in four patients I see.  

2) Inactivity

The longer we sit, the less physically active we are. Physical inactivity shortens our lives.  It is the 4th leading cause of death.  Physical inactivity is the second greatest contributor, behind tobacco smoking, to the cancer burden in Australia.  Physical inactivity is estimated to be the main cause for approximately 25% of breast and colon cancers, 27% of diabetes, and approximately 30% of ischaemic heart disease.

From an evolutionary point of view we’ve had 100,000 generations of being hunter-gatherers, moving around, doing different things all day.  We’ve only had 10 generations of industry, where we do the one thing all day, commonly including too much sitting.  Our bodies just aren't used to sitting for long periods of time. 
Sitting Disease
Sounds terrible? However, the solution is easy…

New research has found that getting up and moving around for two minutes every hour is associated with a 33% lower risk of dying prematurely.  

Breaking up the sitting time appears to be more beneficial to life expectancy than doing daily exercise.  You can eliminate the harmful effects of sitting 10 hours a day by getting up for 2 mins every hour.

Breaking up sitting time also is also good for back pain.  

I’ve spent years trying to get people to sit with better posture to prevent back pain.  It’s super hard to maintain.  It takes continuous deliberate effort, which is almost impossible.  I’ve tried posture -aids, ergonomic chairs, lumbar supports, cushions, Swiss balls, taping.  I’ve given up.  You just can’t sit with perfect posture for long periods of time.  

I’ve now moved to trying to get people to get up and move for a couple of minutes every 20 minutes.  You can get away with sitting with the worst posture imaginable if you don’t stay there too long.  Overall it takes a lot less thought and effort for a much better result.

I think the change to less sitting needs to be driven by employers over the next few years, similar to how smoking was fazed out of work places.  I think we will see more stand-up desks, stand-up meetings, "walk-around" meetings, and possibly enforced limits on sitting time. 

So whether or not we do it for our backs or for a long life, we need to sit less & move more.



More information
19 Comments

“Do I Need an MRI?”

16/5/2015

1 Comment

 
In Australia a lot of money is wasted on unnecessary medical tests.  This means testing to confirm a diagnosis that is already obvious, and tests where the results won’t change the course of treatment.  

A physio example is MRI for knee injuries. Clinical tests I do in the rooms give an accurate diagnosis.  An MRI usually isn’t necessary & can be reserved for cases where the surgeon needs to decide on the type of operation to perform.  If the knee is not a candidate for surgery, then an MRI isn’t going to change the course of rehabilitation.
MRI fridge magnet

Similarly with back and neck pain.  Low back pain is the most commonly imaged musculoskeletal complaint.  A healthcare professional may send you for an x-ray / CT / MRI to confirm a diagnosis or “rule out” something serious.  Unfortunately the imaging rarely adds any additional information, and can actually make things worse.
Back pain is very common. It’s the most common musculoskeletal injury, and essentially everyone will have a sore back at some stage in their lives.  Because it’s so common, we know a lot about it.

In nearly all cases, back pain is not serious and we can reach an accurate diagnosis without needing scans.

We can rule out the scary, “worst case” diagnoses like fractures, infections, & tumours with some simple questions.  We can test for potentially serious “structural” injuries with some simple tests in the rooms. 

However, back pain is rarely anything structural or serious, and imaging doesn’t add any useful information.  Research tells us having a scan doesn’t change the treatment you need, or how fast you recover. We know nearly everyone recovers from back pain without needing a scan.

“Is imaging just a waste of time & money?”

If you’ve got time and money, “what’s the harm?”. Well firstly, X-rays and CT scans expose you to radiation that can potentially cause cancers, so should only be performed when there is a clear benefit. Back X-rays deliver about 65 times more radiation than a chest X-ray.  Back CTs expose you to 100 - 500 times the radiation of a chest X-ray.  Would you volunteer for 500 X-rays if there wasn’t a clear benefit?
CT radiation
Possibly a bigger concern is, when we start scanning body parts, we see things.
Scary MRI
MRIs can look nasty. There’s way too much detail. We see disc degeneration, disc bulges, degenerative joint disease, osteoarthritis, narrowing.  But all of this is normal.

A study of adults without any back pain found that two-thirds of us have bulging discs or other spinal abnormalities on MRI scans. No pain. Bulging discs. So the bulging discs we see if we MRI your back pain are normal, and not something to worry about.

Imaging for back pain shows us a lot of incidental findings that are unrelated to the pain.  The changes we see on a scan don’t require any treatment. The radiologist writes a big long list of “problems”, however, they are just normal changes that were most likely there before you had your pain, and will most likely still be there once your pain has gone. 

Seeing these normal changes on the scan causes stress and anxiety, and potentially unnecessary follow-up tests and procedures, that add to the severity of the injury.

Studies have found that back pain sufferers who had an MRI, compared to similar people with the same severity of injury:
  • consumed higher doses of pain-relief medicines
  • were off work, on average almost 6 times longer
  • if the pain was severe, were 8 times more likely to have surgery
  • if the pain wasn’t severe, were 33 times more likely to have surgery than those who did not have an MRI. 

Even though they had the same symptoms. Just because they’ve had a scan.  A lot of reasons not to get a scan.

Once we’ve seen something on a scan our expectations of recovery change, and that becomes self-fulfilling. If you think your back pain is serious it becomes more painful and takes longer to get better.
“So choose wisely when your back hurts; remember that even brutal back pain is rarely a sign of serious pathology and that it’s really, really common.”

More information available here, here, & here.

A nice video here.
1 Comment

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015

    Categories

    All
    Achilles
    ACL
    Active Transport
    Acupuncture
    Ageing
    AHPRA
    Alcohol
    Ankle
    Ankylosing Spondylitis
    Apps
    Arthritis
    Arthroscopy
    #askyourphysio
    Babies
    Backpacks
    Back Pain
    Blood Pressure
    BMI
    Body Image
    Bunions
    Bursitis
    Cancer
    Chiro
    Chiropractic
    Cholesterol
    Chronic Pain
    Concussion
    Copenhagen
    Costochondritis
    Cramp
    Crossfit
    Cycling
    Dance
    Dementia
    Depression
    De Quervains
    Diet
    Dieting
    Elbow
    Exercise
    Falls
    Fat
    Feet
    Fibromyalgia
    Fibula
    Finger
    Fitness Test
    Food
    Foot
    Fracture
    Fractures
    Glucosamine
    Golfers Elbow
    Groin
    GTN
    Hamstring
    Health
    Heart Disease
    Heart Failure
    Heat
    HIIT Training
    Hip Fracture
    Hydration
    Hyperalgesia
    Ibuprofen
    Injections
    Injury
    Injury Prevention
    Isometric Exercise
    Knee
    Knee Arthroscopy
    Knee Replacement
    Knees
    LARs Ligament Reconstruction
    Lisfranc
    Load
    Low Back Pain
    Massage
    Meditation
    Meniscus
    Minimalist Shoes
    MRI
    MS
    Multiple Sclerosis
    Netball
    Nutrition
    OA
    Obesity
    Orthotics
    Osgood-Schlatter
    Osteoarthritis
    Osteopath
    Osteoperosis
    Pain
    Parkinsons
    Patella
    Peroneal-tendonitis
    Physical-activity
    Physio
    Physio Mosman
    Pigeon-toed
    Pilates
    Piriformis
    Pokemon
    Posture
    Prehab
    Prolotherapy
    Pronation
    PRP
    Radiology
    Recovery
    Rehab
    Rheumatoid
    Rheumatoid-arthritis
    Rotator Cuff
    RTP
    Rugby
    Running
    Running Shoes
    Scan
    Severs
    Shin-pain
    Shoes
    Shoulder
    Shoulder Dislocation
    Sitting
    Sleep
    Soccer
    Spinal Fusion
    Spondyloarthritis
    Spondylolisthesis
    Sports Injury
    Sports Physio
    Standing
    Standing-desk
    Statins
    Stem-cells
    Stress Fracture
    Stretching
    Sugar
    Supplements
    Surgery
    Sweat
    Tendinopathy
    Tendinosis
    Tendonitis
    Tmj
    Treatment
    Vertigo
    Walking
    Warm-Up
    Weight Loss
    Wheezing
    Whiplash
    Wrist
    Yoga

    RSS Feed

Fit As A Physio
ADDRESS: Suite B, 44 Harbour St
PHONE: 99696925
EMAIL: Click Here
BOOK ONLINE
Sports Medicine Australia Member
Austrlaian Physiotherapy Association Member
Picture
MENU

HOME
BOOK ONLINE
​
VIDEO CONSULT
SHOP
CONTACT
​
PARKING
ABOUT
FEES
​
PRIVATE HEALTH INSURANCE
MEDICARE
WORKERS COMP
CTP GREEN SLIP
REVIEWS
FAQS
​GIFT VOUCHERS
MASSAGE
DRY NEEDLING
K-TAPE
WATERPROOF CASTS
ORTHOTICS
MOSMAN RUGBY
VIDEO LIBRARY
LINKS
PODCASTS
DOWNLOADS
BLOG

INJURY INFO

  • Back Pain
  • Sciatica
  • Neck Pain
  • Whiplash
  • Shoulder Pain
  • Rotator Cuff
  • Frozen Shoulder
  • Shin Splints
  • Ankle Sprain
  • Syndesmosis Injury
  • Achilles
  • Sever's Disease
  • Hamstring Injury
  • Hamstring Rehab
  • Hamstring Prehab​
  • Groin Prehab
  • Heel Pain
  • Tennis Elbow
  • AC Joint​
INJURY INFO
  • ​​Quads Cork
  • Patellofemoral Pain
  • Osgood Schlatter's
  • ITB Runners Knee
  • Knee Arthroscope
  • Concussion
  • Stress Fractures
  • ACL Rehab
  • Tendinopathy
  • Load Management
  • Training-Stress Balance
  • Injury Prevention
  • Stretching
  • Recovery
  • Alignment
  • Injections
  • Osteoarthritis
  • Vertigo

​PHYSIO MOSMAN

Copyright© 2022| Fit As A Physio | ABN 62855169241 | All rights reserved | Sitemap
  • Home
  • COVID-19
  • Book Online
  • Reviews
  • FAQS
  • Fees
  • Contact
  • SHOP